There is no universal definition of what specific qualities a song must have to be considered a “Christian” song. Here are some opinions:
– The song lyrics must reflect biblical truth.
– The song lyrics must directly praise God/Jesus.
– The song must mention God/Jesus.
– The song must be written for Christians and not as an evangelical tool.
– The lyrics must directly address God, not other people.
– The song must be completely new, not a cover of a secular song.
– The song is designed to be played in church, not outside of church.
– The melody must be paramount, and the rhythm subdued.
– The song must be written and performed by mature Christians only.
– The men who sing the song must have short hair, and the women must have long hair.
There are several aspects of a song that may influence its categorization as “Christian music,” but these qualifiers suggest almost as many problems as solutions. And many of them focus on everything except the message of the song.
Christian Music – The Writers/Performers
Many consider a song to be “Christian” only if it is performed by an artist in the Christian music industry and played on Christian radio stations. However, if the lyrics of a song written and performed by Christians for a Christian audience misinterpret Scripture, can it still be considered “Christian music”? Can a slightly modified cover of a secular song by a Christian artist for a Christian audience be considered “Christian music”? Kansas’s “Carry on Wayward Son” performed by Rachel Rachel and Matt Brouwer’s cover of Sheryl Crow’s “I Shall Believe” come to mind. Or what about songs written and performed by someone once billed as a Christian artist who now lives an unbiblical lifestyle? If the lyrics speak spiritual truth, does the origin of the song matter?
The band is affiliated with Hillsong Church, a Christian megachurch initially founded in Australia in 1983 that has since spread across the world with its modern take on evangelical Christianity.
Hillsong Church has attracted a young adult demographic, including celebrities such as Justin Bieber and Chris Pratt, yet has faced criticism over its conservative views on homosexuality and abortion. Hillsong UNITED’s presence on campus this summer has sparked mixed reactions from the BU community over the group’s conservative policies, as well.
In August 2017, Hillsong Church founding Pastor Brian Houston released a statement in which he urged Australians to vote against same-sex marriage legalization. In August 2015, Houston said the church would accept gay members into the community but would not allow them to take on active leadership roles.
“Hillsong Church welcomes ALL people but does not affirm all lifestyles,” Houston wrote in a press release. “Put clearly, we do not affirm a gay lifestyle and because of this we do not knowingly have actively gay people in positions of leadership, either paid or unpaid.”
More recently, the church released another statement on Feb. 14 stating they are not “anti-anyone” and that they love and welcome all people regardless of their backgrounds or identities.
Hillsong Church has a location in downtown Boston on Tremont Street.
Dielle Lundberg, a graduate student in the School of Public Health and an executive board member for BU’s Queer Alliance, wrote in an email Hillsong Church’s toleration of LGBTQ people does not undo its decades of pain and psychological impacts on the community.
“What would be a step in the right direction is if the organization paid for independent LGBTQ+ educators to train leadership on basic sexual orientation and gender competency and included such education in all major programming such as the Agganis Arena event,” Lundberg wrote.
BU spokesperson Colin Riley said Agganis Arena would not be commenting on Hillsong UNITED’s summer performance.
Hillsong Church did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
Hillsong Church also came under fire in November 2018 for a different reason after Brett Sengstock said on “60 Minutes” he was the victim of child abuse at the hands of Frank Houston, who was a Pentecostal Christian pastor and father of Hillsong Church founder Brian Houston.
In a statement about the accusations, Hillsong Church denied there was a lack of transparency by its leadership and said the criminal allegations occured before Hillsong Church existed.
Despite criticism of the church, the affiliated band’s song “Oceans (Where Feet May Fail)” topped Billboard’s Hot Christian Songs chart in 2013, and more recently their song “So Will I (100 Billion X)” peaked at No. 3 on the chart in 2018.
Andrew Chiao, Senate Chair of the BU Student Government, said he has never heard of the band, so his opinion is limited, but that the group should not be discounted with little thought.
“I think that an ultra-conservative group or performance should be given equal consideration to perform on campus,” Chiao said.
However, Chiao said, a group that spreads hateful messages should not be allowed to perform at Agganis because hate speech is not permitted at BU.
Hillsong UNITED’s song lyrics refrain from social and political themes, instead focusing on messages of worship.
Julia Lanham, an advisor for the School of Public Health Queer Alliance, wrote in an email Hillsong Church has never shown support for LGBTQ people and has harmed the community over the years.
“I am under the assumption that BU did not know about this group’s homophobic history when they booked this concert at Agganis Arena,” Lanham wrote. “I hope the university will take steps to rectify the situation either by canceling the concert or requiring Hillsong to take meaningful, public action in support of LGBTQ+ people – particularly youth – prior to any event on campus.”
Riley said the acts that perform at Agganis Arena are generally recognized artists, and Hillsong UNITED is no different.
“It’s one of the finest new venues in the last dozen years or more,” Riley said. “We work with established, reputable and high-quality promoters.”
Zachary Bos, administrative coordinator for the College of Arts and Sciences’ Core Curriculum and Massachusetts director for American Atheists, wrote in an email there have been talks about protests of this concert.
“I’ve been moderating discussion among some local secular (humanist, atheist, and skeptic) groups, about the possibility of a protest demonstration of some kind,” Bos wrote.
Maya Jones, a freshman in College of Communication, said she thinks the scheduled performance is offensive to a lot of students at BU.
“I do not think that BU should let them play here,” Jones said. “They should be wary of groups that are super controversial.”
David Hou, a freshman in CAS, said he thinks whether or not Hillsong UNITED is welcome on campus is BU’s decision to make as a private university.
“I haven’t heard of Hillsong as an extremist institution, so I guess that’s a decision of the university,” Hou said.
Riley said Agganis Arena has had success over the years, and that eclectic groups and performers have come to do shows at the mid-size venue.
“One of the benefits of having Agganis Arena is it generates revenue for the university’s operating budget, and not only covers the cost of hosting the show,” Riley said.
Meagan Cassidy Coyle, a junior in College of Arts and Sciences, said she thinks the school strives to appear inclusive, but hosting a church band that is affiliated with anti-LGBTQ or sexual abuse scandals demonstrates its financially driven nature.
Coyle said while it is important that finances at the school be maintained, she thinks it is more important that students are protected against discrimination.
“Agganis Arena absolutely has a say in which groups perform at BU,” Coyle said, “especially when financial gains are associated with the invitation.”Source
“Have I therefore become your enemy by telling you the truth?”
For those people who don’t believe God exist and waste so much time trying to convince everyone else he doesn’t exist…
Justice is a word that stands alone, adding anything to it demeans it….
It is impossible to find anyone in the Bible who was a power for God who did not have enemies and was not hated.
8.8K Views On YouTube
MY MISSION IS NOT TO CONVINCE YOU, ONLY TO INFORM…
Jesus come quick, there is nothing left in society that’s sacred….
The number of Orphans aging out of Child Protective Custody has grown at an alarming rate. The 127 Faith Foundation receives many requests each week to house them at our ranch. Our prayer is that the good people of our country will step up to the challenge and offer financial support for "the least among us." We need your help! StevieRay Hansen, Founder, The 127 Faith Foundation
We make every effort to acknowledge sources used in our news articles. In a few cases, the sources were lost due to a technological glitch. If you believe we have not given sufficient credit for your source material, please contact us, and we will be more than happy to link to your article.